A Dessert Worth Drooling Over: Meet the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake

Ever find yourself craving a dessert that hits all the right notes — rich chocolate, creamy peanut butter, and just enough nostalgia to make you smile? That’s exactly what this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake delivers.

If you’re a twenty-something balancing adulting with a love for indulgent desserts, this one’s for you. It’s like your childhood favorite got a grown-up makeover — rolled up into a decadent, photogenic slice. I first whipped this up for a game night with friends, and let’s just say it didn’t survive past halftime.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Rich chocolate sponge that melts in your mouth
• A whipped peanut butter filling so smooth it’s basically velvet
• Chopped Reese’s cups for that crunch and extra flavor burst

Want more like this? Check out Giant Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Pie for a no-roll alternative, or explore No-Bake Twix Cheesecake for another candy-inspired hit.

And according to Food52, Americans buy over 400 million Reese’s cups annually — so yes, this flavor combo is more than just trendy. It’s iconic.

What Makes Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake Unique?

Let’s be honest: not every dessert deserves its own spotlight. But this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake? It practically demands it. What sets it apart isn’t just the ingredients — it’s the balance of textures, nostalgic appeal, and sheer crowd-pleasing power.

A Perfect Trio of Textures

• Soft chocolate sponge: Think light, airy, and moist — this isn’t your average dense chocolate cake. The base rolls beautifully without cracking and has just enough structure to hold the filling.
• Fluffy peanut butter cream: A blend of creamy peanut butter and whipped topping makes for a filling that’s light on the palate but rich in flavor. It reminds me of the whipped peanut butter dip my mom used to sneak into lunchboxes.
• Crunchy Reese’s bits on top: That final sprinkle of chopped peanut butter cups adds a playful contrast. Sweet, salty, and just a little rebellious.

And let’s not forget: desserts like this are designed to bring people together. Whether you’re baking for brunch or a birthday, it’s a guaranteed conversation-starter — just like these Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies, which are just as easy to devour.

Even Serious Eats notes that the magic of peanut butter and chocolate lies in their complementary fat and sugar profiles — making them a scientifically satisfying combo. That’s why this cake works on every level.

Need another reason? According to a 2023 consumer trend report by Statista, over 60% of millennials prefer desserts that combine texture and flavor variety. No surprise this roll cake always disappears first.

Ingredients Breakdown: Build a Cake That Steals the Show

The beauty of this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake is that it looks fancy but keeps the ingredient list refreshingly simple. Whether you’re leaning into a boxed mix or baking from scratch, the real magic is in how everything comes together.

a. For the Cake

You can absolutely take the shortcut route with a boxed chocolate cake mix — and let’s be real, we’ve all had weeks when that’s the vibe. But if you want a homemade version (and a little extra bragging rights), you’ll need:

• ¾ cup all-purpose flour
• ¼ cup cocoa powder
• 1 tsp baking powder
• 4 large eggs
• ¾ cup granulated sugar
• 1 tsp vanilla extract

The sponge is key here. It needs to be light enough to roll without cracking, but moist enough to stay tender after chilling. Curious about alternative sweet bakes? This healthy sweet potato chocolate cake is surprisingly good and follows similar texture logic.

b. For the Filling

This is where things get rich:

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter
• 2 cups whipped topping (or heavy cream for a homemade version)
• Optional: ½ stick butter and powdered sugar for added structure

Want expert insight? The Kitchn recommends stabilizing whipped fillings with a touch of powdered sugar — especially if you plan to refrigerate overnight.

c. For the Topping

The final flourish should be indulgent but not over-the-top:

• 1 cup chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
• Optional: a drizzle of chocolate ganache or a dollop of whipped cream

Bonus tip: Try a variation with cheesecake fruit salad folded into the topping layer — it adds contrast and a summery twist.

Tools & Equipment You’ll Actually Use

Before you dive in, make sure your kitchen is stocked with a few key tools that make this roll cake foolproof. Don’t worry — no fancy gadgets required.

Your Must-Have Tools:

• Jelly roll pan – This shallow, rimmed baking sheet is essential for getting that thin, rollable sponge. A regular sheet pan won’t give you the right texture.
• Parchment paper – A lifesaver when it comes to mess-free removal and even baking.
• Clean kitchen towel – Helps you roll the cake without sticking or tearing. Pro tip: dust it with powdered sugar.
• Spatula + mixing bowls – Use a flexible spatula to gently fold batter and a few sturdy bowls for prep.
• Electric mixer – Hand or stand mixer works — just be sure it can whip eggs until pale and fluffy.

Need more baking hacks? Check out this no-bake banana cheesecake on Sozan Recipes — another dessert that comes together fast with minimal tools.

For curious minds: America’s Test Kitchen notes that using the right pan size and lining it correctly can reduce cracking in cake rolls by over 70%. Translation? These tools aren’t optional — they’re your success insurance.

How to Make Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake: Step-by-Step Guide

Making a cake roll may sound intimidating, but it’s surprisingly approachable once you get the rhythm. Think of it as baking with a little choreography — some timing, a gentle touch, and confidence.

Step 1: Preheat & Line the Pan

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). Grab a 10×15-inch jelly roll pan and line it with parchment paper — not optional. Lightly grease the paper to ensure your chocolate sponge lifts without a fight. If you’ve ever made something like this Strawberry Earthquake Cake, you already know the importance of nonstick prep.

Step 2: Make the Cake Batter

Follow your cake mix instructions or whisk up a homemade batter (see our earlier section). Beat your eggs until pale and fluffy. This aeration creates structure and flexibility, so don’t rush it. According to King Arthur Baking, underwhipped eggs are a leading cause of cracking in rolled cakes.

Step 3: Bake Carefully – Tips to Prevent Cracking

Spread the batter evenly and bake for about 12–15 minutes, watching closely. The goal? A firm but flexible sponge that springs back when touched. Overbake and it’ll crumble instead of roll.

Step 4: Roll the Cake While Warm

Here’s where most people panic. Don’t. Gently invert your cake onto a powdered-sugar-dusted towel. Peel off the parchment and roll from the short end while it’s still warm. Yes, warm — that’s the key.

Step 5: Cooling Tips – Maintaining the Shape

Let it cool completely while rolled. This step “trains” the cake to hold its shape. I usually tuck it in the fridge for 30 minutes — long enough to set, short enough not to dry out. While it cools, why not browse Cheesecake-Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies for your next baking win?

Making the Peanut Butter Filling

This is the heart of your Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake — the part where flavor meets texture in a perfectly creamy swirl. The filling comes together in minutes and makes the entire cake feel like a bakery-level dessert.

Ingredients for the Filling:

• 1 cup creamy peanut butter
• 2 cups whipped topping (or substitute with stabilized whipped cream)
• Optional: 2 tbsp softened butter and ¼ cup powdered sugar for extra richness and hold

Here’s where it gets personal — I once tried subbing in crunchy peanut butter for texture. Big mistake. Smooth peanut butter blends best, especially when paired with a light whipped topping. The goal? A texture that spreads like mousse but doesn’t ooze out the sides.

If you’re prepping ahead or serving in warmer weather, consider stabilizing your whipped topping. According to The Kitchn, a small amount of powdered sugar helps maintain that fluffy consistency and resists weeping.

And if you’re a peanut butter superfan, this Peanut Butter Banana Smoothie might be your new breakfast obsession.

Assembling the Roll Cake

Now comes the part that feels like a magic trick — turning a flat sponge into a beautifully rolled dessert. It’s all about technique and timing.

Here’s how to get it right:

• Unroll the cake gently: Take your time. If it cracks a little, don’t panic — frosting hides all sins.
• Spread the filling evenly: Use an offset spatula and leave a ½-inch border so it doesn’t squish out during rolling.
• Roll it back up: This time, ditch the towel. Keep it tight but not forced, letting the cake guide you.
• Place seam-side down: This keeps it intact and makes for a cleaner presentation.

Presentation-wise, you can keep it simple or dress it up like this Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake — a dessert that’s just as bold in flavor as it is in color.

As America’s Test Kitchen recommends, always chill the cake before slicing. It helps the layers firm up and makes those swirl cuts look like something from a pastry shop window.

Decorating and Garnishing the Cake

This is where your Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake transforms from delicious to jaw-dropping. A few simple touches go a long way.

Add the Final Flair:

• Sprinkle extra chopped Reese’s on top — texture + visual drama
• Add a swirl of whipped topping or a glossy chocolate ganache drizzle
• Chill the cake for at least 1 hour before slicing to ensure clean, bakery-style layers

When I served this at my sister’s engagement dinner, I paired the decor style with elements from this Strawberry Cheesecake Nacho spread — both whimsical and elevated.

If you’re going all out, Bon Appétit recommends a ganache made with equal parts cream and chocolate — easy and elegant.

Serving Suggestions

This cake is more than dessert — it’s a mood. Serve it right, and you’ll elevate the whole experience.

Try These Pairings:

• A chilled glass of milk for the nostalgic vibe
• A bold espresso or cold brew to cut the sweetness
• A scoop of vanilla bean ice cream for contrast

Plating Ideas & Occasions

• Slice diagonally for a café-style presentation
• Garnish plates with a drizzle of ganache or peanut butter sauce
• Perfect for birthdays, date nights, or even Friendsgiving — just like this No-Bake Peppermint Cheesecake is ideal for holiday potlucks

Want to impress with zero stress? Serious Eats suggests prepping all garnishes in advance to streamline last-minute plating.

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips

This cake is as practical as it is pretty — great for prepping ahead.

Here’s How to Store It:

• Refrigerate tightly wrapped for up to 3–4 days
• For best texture, slice just before serving
• Freeze uncut cake (without toppings) for up to 1 month — wrap in plastic + foil

Hosting tomorrow? Make the roll today, chill overnight, and decorate the next day. That’s my move when balancing dinner prep with dessert detail — and it works, just like it did with this Classic Cherry Delight.

According to King Arthur Baking, sponge cakes hold their moisture well, making them excellent candidates for make-ahead menus.

Nutrition Information

Let’s be real — this isn’t diet food, and that’s kind of the point. Each slice of this Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Roll Cake clocks in at around 450–500 calories, depending on your toppings and serving size.

Quick Nutritional Breakdown (per slice):

• Servings: 10–12
• Fat: ~28g
• Carbs: ~45g
• Protein: ~6g

Thanks to the peanut butter filling and chocolate sponge, you’re getting a decadent mix of fats and sugars with a touch of protein. Want a lighter follow-up? Pair your slice with a fruit-forward option like this Easy Strawberry Cool Whip Pie.

According to Harvard Health, peanut butter provides heart-healthy monounsaturated fats — so yes, you can indulge with a little less guilt.

Troubleshooting and Tips for Success

Even pros have cake catastrophes — but you can avoid most with a few simple tricks.

Avoid Common Mistakes:

• Cake cracking? You likely overbaked or didn’t roll while warm. Be quick but gentle.
• Roll too loose or too tight? Use a towel for structure, but don’t press too hard.
• Filling too runny? Chill it first or add a bit of powdered sugar for stability.
• Messy slices? Refrigerate the roll before cutting and use a serrated knife for clean edges.

My first attempt? A chocolate lava mess. But with a chilled roll and slow slicing, the result was clean swirls worth posting. Check out these Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies for another dessert where precision pays off.

The Spruce Eats also recommends using unflavored dental floss for perfect, clean cake slices — it sounds wild, but it works.

FAQs – People Also Ask

Can you use store-bought cake mix for roll cakes?

Yes — absolutely. In fact, a good-quality chocolate cake mix can save you time without sacrificing flavor. Just be sure it’s light enough for rolling. I’ve used one in a pinch for this recipe and no one knew the difference. Looking to upgrade the flavor? Add a teaspoon of espresso powder — a trick I picked up from Sally’s Baking Addiction that deepens the chocolate notes.

How do you stop a roll cake from cracking?

Timing is everything. Roll the cake while it’s still warm, ideally right out of the oven. Also, don’t overbake — dry cakes crack. King Arthur Baking suggests baking just until the sponge springs back when lightly touched. For an added visual, check out the texture cues in this Blueberry Cheesecake Stuffed French Toast.

Can I make this roll cake ahead of time?

Definitely. The cake can be made and filled a day in advance — just wrap it tightly and refrigerate. Decorate just before serving to keep the toppings fresh.

What’s the best way to store leftovers?

Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 3–4 days. For longer storage, freeze it (undecorated) and thaw overnight.

Is there a gluten-free or dairy-free alternative?

Yes! Use a gluten-free chocolate cake mix and swap whipped topping with coconut cream or another dairy-free substitute. Pair it with something equally allergen-friendly like this No-Bake Banana Cheesecake.

Can I add Reese’s to the filling instead of just topping?

Totally — just chop them fine to maintain the smooth, spreadable texture. It adds great crunch and flavor to the middle swirl.

Print